Trust the process, do the work: A father's perspective on trying to conceive

Personal Stories & Support

Preconception

Sperm Health

Trust the process, do the work: A father's perspective on trying to conceive

Some conversations remind us why a father's perspective on trying to conceive deserves far more space than it usually gets, and our conversation with Dr. Jeremy Brook was one of them. Jeremy is a chiropractor in Encinitas, CA a husband to Dr. Kristyn Silver-Brook, and a dad of three, and he talks about fertility the way he seems to approach most of life: with humor, conviction, a deep spiritual streak, and an enormous amount of love for his family.

From the outside, Jeremy looked like the last person who would worry about conceiving. He was lifting heavy, sleeping well, and following a supplement routine he proudly calls world class. Yet when the first couple of months of trying came and went without a positive test, a quiet question crept in that he never said out loud to anyone: at 45, could it be him?

That unspoken question is exactly why stories like his matter. For so long, the fertility conversation has centered almost entirely on women, while men are expected to stay calm, stay strong, and keep any doubt to themselves. At WeNatal, we believe men are 50% of the fertility equation, not to add pressure, but because their health, their habits, and their emotional experience are part of the story from the very beginning.

In his own words, Jeremy shares the honeymoon he was sure would end with a baby, why he and Kristyn stepped back from tracking, a stormy night their family will never forget, and the advice he would give any man who is quietly carrying doubt. Along the way, you will find short notes from our team that add research context to his experience.


RELATED:
Male fertility and fatherhood: Shawn's Father's Day story


What is trying to conceive like from a father's perspective? For many men, it involves far more emotion than they show. Dr. Jeremy Brook describes carrying quiet doubt about his age and sperm health while staying calm for his wife, and his advice is to get tested, correct what you can, care for your health, and never carry the doubt alone.


Key takeaways

  • Not conceiving in the first month or two is common. In one prospective study of couples who timed intercourse to ovulation, about 68% conceived within three cycles.

  • Men feel the pressure too, even when they look calm on the outside, and Jeremy quietly wondered "is it me?" at 45 without ever saying it out loud.

  • Male age is one factor worth understanding, since research links advancing age with gradual changes in some semen parameters, which is a reason to get informed rather than worried.

  • A semen analysis and basic bloodwork can turn guessing into real information for both partners.

  • Everyday habits like nutrition, heat exposure, sleep, and stress support are within a man's influence, and supplementation can be one part of that foundation.


Who I am: A chiropractor, a husband, and a dad of three

I'm Dr. Jeremy Brook, a 53-year-old chiropractor in Encinitas, CAand I'm married to an amazing woman, Dr. Kristyn Silver-Brook. She's the best life partner and the best mom to our kids, and I tell her that every single day. I tell the kids too, so they grow up knowing how badass their mom is.

We have three kids: two boys, who are seven and four, and a one-year-old daughter. Getting here didn't look exactly the way I pictured it, and I've learned that the parts of this journey men don't usually talk about are often the parts other men most need to hear.


I was sure it would happen on our honeymoon

Honestly, I expected it to be immediate. We got married in November and flew to New Zealand and the Polynesian Islands for our honeymoon (Moorea was incredible), and between all the eating, drinking, and being merry, getting pregnant on that trip just seemed like a given.

It didn't happen straight away with our first, and that's when the disappointment set in. Month one came and went with nothing, and so did month two. Kristyn had been tracking closely the whole time with her Oura ring and ovulation strips, and because we were following those numbers so carefully, every month without a positive test made the disappointment build a little more. Doubt started creeping into my mind, so we decided to go into full trust mode, drop the apps, and relax into it. In month three, it happened.

Our second was a completely different story. Kristyn said, "It's time to make a baby," I said, "Okay," and bam, that was it. Baby number three came on the first try, too, so we were truly blessed, and I like to say it was just meant to be.

The science, from the WeNatal team: Is it normal not to get pregnant right away?

If month one and month two feel discouraging, Jeremy and Kristyn's timeline is actually very typical. In a prospective study of 346 women who timed intercourse using fertility awareness methods, the estimated chance of conceiving was about 38% in the first cycle, 68% within three cycles, and 81% within six. Two months without a positive test rarely means something is wrong, even though it can absolutely feel that way when you are the one living it.


RELATED:
How to start ovulation and hormone tracking for conception


Why we stopped tracking ovulation, and what I'd tell other couples

I can still picture the moment I realized things might look different than I'd imagined. We were upstairs in our bedroom during that second month when Kristyn told me her period had come, and I could feel the disappointment and tension building between us. I told her what I truly believed, which was that we're both super healthy and this was just divine timing.

That building disappointment, and the pressure that came with it, was the biggest challenge we faced, and it only happened with our first. After month two, I suggested we stop the apps, stop the tracking, and go into full trust mode. Stress can create weird physiology on the inside, and I didn't want that working against us. So my advice to other couples is simple: don't get too attached to the ring and the strips.

The science, from the WeNatal team: Tracking is a tool, not a report card

Jeremy's instinct to step back from the apps is worth unpacking, because tracking itself is not the problem. Conception is most likely when intercourse happens during the roughly six-day fertile window that ends on the day of ovulation, and ovulation tracking can help couples find that window. In fact, the couples in the study above were actively tracking their cycles.

Where tracking can become harder is when the data starts to feel like a monthly grade. Research on stress and conception is still developing, and one prospective U.S. study of 501 couples found that women with the highest levels of a salivary stress marker (alpha-amylase) took longer to conceive, while cortisol showed no association. That is an association rather than proof that stress causes delays, and no one should feel blamed for feeling anxious while trying. The gentler takeaway is to use tracking as a tool, notice when it starts running your emotional life, and give yourselves permission to adjust, just as Jeremy and Kristyn did.


RELATED:
What to do when you're stressed about the stress of TTC


Being the rock while quietly asking, "Is it me?"

With our first, I absolutely felt pressure to be the strong one. I was telling Kristyn it was divine timing while carrying my own doubt, because I see my job as being the rock for my wife, and if she doesn't have a strong rock to lean on, we've got trouble.

What I never shared with her was a quiet thought that crept in when I was 45: is it me? I know guys like Al Pacino are making babies in their 80s, but part of me still wondered whether I was the reason we hadn't conceived right away. I told myself there was no way I couldn't make a baby, period, but the thought was there, and if month three hadn't worked, I probably would have started stressing that something was off.

The science, from the WeNatal team: Does a man's age affect fertility?

Jeremy's quiet question is one many men over 40 ask, and it deserves a real answer. A systematic review and meta-analysis of 90 studies including nearly 94,000 men found that semen volume, motility (how well sperm move), normal morphology (sperm shape), and DNA integrity tend to decline gradually with age, while sperm concentration did not show the same decline.

That does not mean a man in his 40s or 50s cannot become a father, and Jeremy's three children are a happy example. It means age is one piece of the picture worth understanding, and a semen analysis can replace a worried guess with actual information.


RELATED:
Advanced paternal age: Men's age, sperm, and fertility


What I knew about male fertility, and why I'd tell every man to get tested

From the man's side, I always believed it comes down to making sure the sperm is strong and has great motility, because that's the core of it. For me, supplementation was essential because I wanted good, strong, viable sperm, so I made sure that part was dialed in, and I was definitely taking my vitamins.

I'll be honest that I never got tested, but I wasn't flying blind, either. I had bloodwork done, my testosterone was good, and I learned I have an MTHFR gene variant, so I took methylated supplements. Looking back, I'd say it plainly to any man reading this: get tested, and if it shows a deficiency you can correct, correct it.

What I wish more men understood is that it takes two to tango. People tend to think getting pregnant is the woman's job, but the sperm has to be healthy enough to swim and fertilize the egg, and if it isn't, conception gets a lot harder.

The science, from the WeNatal team: Why testing matters for men, too

Male factors are estimated to contribute to about half of all couples' fertility challenges, yet men are often evaluated later than their partners, if at all. A semen analysis measures sperm count, motility, and morphology, and alongside bloodwork, it can give both partners a clearer picture early on.

A quick note on MTHFR: this gene provides instructions for an enzyme that helps the body produce the active form of folate. Common variants are widespread and can reduce the enzyme's activity, making it less efficient for the body to produce active folate from folic acid and food folate. Some people prefer methylated nutrients such as L-methylfolate, the active form of folate, because the body does not need to convert it. If you know your MTHFR status, it is worth discussing with your provider how it fits into your overall nutrition plan.


RELATED:
Q&A with reproductive urologist Dr. Ariel Moradzadeh


Do men feel comfortable talking about fertility struggles?

I think this generation of men is a lot more open with their feelings. For fathers in their 50s, and maybe even their 60s, it's more generational, so some feel comfortable talking with someone about something this sensitive and some won't. Even now, most of those conversations happen behind closed doors, in a doctor's or therapist's office, and it's not something men are going to post on Instagram, if you know what I mean.

Men have support groups and men's circles these days, too. Personally, I hate going to men's circles, and that's just me, but I'm not shy about sharing anything with a trained professional who's going to help me optimize my life.


RELATED:
Dads don't talk


The night lightning struck

Kristyn was disappointed during those first months, and I could feel it, so my job was to keep us steady. My wife doesn't stress hard because she's very balanced, and even when she is stressed, it's minimally expressed, so this was never full-blown panic so much as a quiet disappointment that grew a little more each month.

I kept reminding her that we were both super healthy and that it was just a matter of divine timing. We stopped with the apps and the tracking and relaxed into it, because sometimes people get so stressed out that it creates weird physiology on the inside, and I didn't want that working against us.

Then came a night I'll never forget. I think it was ovulation week, it was raining, and there was lightning outside, and while we were making love, lightning was striking all around us. I told her, "We made a baby tonight," and sure enough, we found out she was pregnant. That was our first, and it's the reason our son's middle name is Blaze.

I always tell people not to trip and not to stress, because that's where the tension develops. I don't want to call it performance anxiety, but once anxiety takes root, it can get in the way. We calmed down, trusted the process, and it happened.

Looking back, we definitely processed those months differently. Kristyn was tracking closely and feeling the disappointment build, while I was calm on the outside and quietly doubting on the inside.


RELATED:
How to communicate with your partner during any phase of your fertility journey


What I learned about supporting my partner during pregnancy

I'm not saying a man has to bury his feelings during pregnancy, but I do believe, 100%, that his feelings come second. The woman has so much more to do, from carrying the baby to birthing the baby to feeding the baby. As much as I'd like to say the man has a large say in all of it, she carries the ultimate responsibility, and there are things a man simply can't do.

So I saw my job as being the rock and leaning on my wife to make a lot of the decisions. We shared plenty of decisions along the way, but thank God I had a rock star of a wife and mother, so mostly I just needed to support her.

That doesn't mean my feelings didn't matter. Even a rock needs somewhere to set its weight down, and I had my own people and practices for that, which I'll share in a moment. Through all of it, I've been blown away by Kristyn's strength and the mother she's become, and together we've stacked up a lot of resilience.


RELATED:
What partners can do during pregnancy: A practical support guide


My sperm health routine: Nutrition, supplements, and staying grounded

Trying to conceive didn't really change my habits, because I was already dialed in. I was lifting heavy at Deuce Gym in Venice Beach, my Oura ring had my sleep and readiness scores in the 90s, and my supplement regimen was world class. I was taking essential fatty acids, zinc, copper, and selenium, with zinc and selenium playing key roles in healthy sperm formation and motility, plus methylated supplements for my MTHFR variant. Being a chiropractor, if you don't have a solid supplement regimen, what are you doing?

To stay grounded, I leaned on yoga, breathwork, slacklining, and weightlifting, along with my spiritual teachers, a great rabbi, and my Kabbalah and meditation practice. I also turned to voices like Henry Rollins on sharpening the iron and Nassim Nicholas Taleb's Antifragile. I'm self-motivated, but I've got tools.

Health, healing, vitality, and longevity were already the game plan, so this journey didn't change my priorities as much as it confirmed I was on the right path.


RELATED:
Male fertility as a health biomarker: What sperm count reveals about longevity


My practical sperm health tips for men

Take the right supplements for sperm health and motility, choose breathable, natural fabrics like cotton, and be mindful of heat and chemical exposure from synthetics. And if you use a laptop, keep it off your lap, because heat is not your friend down there.

The science, from the WeNatal team: What the research says about heat and supplements

Jeremy's heat advice has research behind it. Sperm production works best a few degrees below core body temperature, which is part of why the testes sit outside the body. In a small study of 29 healthy men, using a working laptop on the lap for an hour raised scrotal temperature by about 2.6 to 2.8°C, and a cross-sectional study of men at a fertility center found that those who mostly wore boxers had about 25% higher sperm concentration than men who wore tighter styles. Neither study proves a direct effect on conception, but both support simple, low-effort habits like using a desk and choosing looser, breathable underwear.

Jeremy calls supplementation essential, and for him it was. A 2018 systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials found that selenium, zinc, omega-3 fatty acids, CoQ10, and carnitines were associated with improvements in certain sperm parameters. On the other hand, a large 2020 randomized trial of folic acid and zinc alone, in more than 2,300 men, found no improvement in semen quality or live birth. Taken together, these findings suggest that nutrition matters, that no single nutrient is a shortcut, and that supplements work best as one part of a broader foundation that includes food, sleep, movement, and stress support.

If Jeremy's regimen sounds like a lot of bottles to keep track of, that is part of why WeNatal for Him exists. It brings together 20 key nutrients and antioxidants,  including methylfolate, zinc, selenium, CoQ10, and acetyl L-carnitine, in one daily routine designed to support healthy sperm production, motility, and overall reproductive wellness.* Omega-3s are kept separate in Omega DHA+, because these oils stay more stable when they are not combined with minerals. As with any supplement, it is worth reviewing your routine with your healthcare provider, especially if you take medications.


RELATED:
Foods for sperm health: How to build a fertility-supportive plate for men


The hardest moment: Advocating for my son after his birth

The most emotionally difficult moment wasn't the birth itself, but what came around it with our first son. We were laboring at home, and after four nights of labor, our midwife didn't like how low his heartbeat was dropping during contractions on that last night. We rushed to the hospital so quickly that the car seat was still in the box with wrapping paper on it, and we didn't have a bag packed, because a hospital birth wasn't in our mindset at all.

At the hospital, they hooked Kristyn up to IVs and monitors and found that everything was good, and she still had an unmedicated, natural childbirth. It wasn't the quiet, red-lit room we'd imagined at home, but it was a great birth, with bright lights, great nurses, and a solid OB who let our midwife and doula run the show.

After the birth is when things got hard, and it became one of the most difficult moments not just of our journey, but of my life. A hospitalist began recommending additional tests and procedures for our son, raised concerns about his health that felt alarming to us, and wanted to keep him for a 48-hour stay. I felt fear, anger, adrenaline, and distrust all at once, and it felt like the scenario we'd talked through in our birth class, being asked to agree to interventions we didn't believe he needed, playing out in real time.

I stayed informed and asked questions, and when I didn't feel the recommendations were right for our son, I said no thank you. All we wanted was to get our family home. Thankfully, I understood what was being proposed, and that was the moment I had to be the rock for my family, with everything in me on high alert.

A note from the WeNatal team: Jeremy's story is his own, and every birth and every newborn is different. What feels universal is the experience he describes: the rush of protectiveness, the fear, and the need to understand what is happening to someone you love. For many parents, advocacy looks like asking what a recommendation is for, what the alternatives are, and what happens if you wait, then making decisions together with a care team you trust.


The support that made the biggest difference

I'm self-motivated, but I did have someone I could talk to openly, a mystical wisdom teacher who is almost like a spiritual psychologist, if you will. I also leaned on a great rabbi and my Kabbalah, yoga, and meditation practice, which are my tools for when things get next level.

The biggest difference for me, though, was having a great midwife and doula. I leaned into their wisdom and guidance for all three births, and especially for our first, because I was 100% green in that arena. In 26 years of practice, I've cared for hundreds of pregnant women, getting them primed for birth, adjusting them on the day they delivered, and adjusting babies the day they were born or shortly after, but that's really where my expertise ended. The birth process wasn't my domain, and the best support we had was our midwife and our doula, period.

My teachers and practices were great for my overall headspace, and I'd tell any man who's in doubt or hurting to get help. Men today are less macho and more able to express emotion, and you can even talk to someone privately over Zoom.

If I could change one thing about how society talks about men, fertility, and fatherhood, it would be to drop the leftover macho stigma. A man should be able to say "I'm struggling" without it being a big deal.


RELATED:
5 reasons to prioritize mental health on your fertility journey


Catching my babies, and what fatherhood taught me

When I look back on how this journey shaped me, the word that comes to mind is blessed. We conceived in month three with our first and right away with the next two. Our first was born at the hospital, and I was putting on gloves when the doctor made the catch, so call it a half catch. The next two were home births, and I caught both of them. With Goldie, I got to be Kristyn's doula alongside our amazing doula, and I had so much fun, even though she did all the work.

If this experience taught me anything about myself, it's how lucky I am to be married to a badass. I'm blown away by Kristyn's strength and the mother she's become, because carrying a baby and breathing it out of your body is no joke.


What I'd say to any man navigating fertility challenges

If you're planning a family, nothing is more important, so get the help you need. There are so many options out there, and there's no reason to go it alone.

Get tested, and if there's a deficiency you can correct, correct it. Don't sit in doubt, shame, or embarrassment, because those low states expand. Instead, visualize the win: your wife walks into the kitchen with a pregnancy test, she's crying, you hug, and you celebrate together. Then go take action.


What I want my kids, and the next generation of fathers, to understand

Family is everything. It's your tribe, your clan, and your connection, and when the family unit weakens, people start slipping. Resilience has to be the backbone, because dark moments can happen in life, and nothing is more important than family or than being there for your kids. Nothing.

My kids, and especially my two sons since my daughter is still young, know that I love them, period. They get kisses, hugs, and physical touch every single day, and there's no way they're going to go through life not knowing that their father loved them more than anything on the planet. I know men who never once heard their dads say they love them, and that will never be my kids' story.


My one message: Never carry the doubt alone

If I could leave you with one message about the male experience of fertility, it's to trust the process, do the work, and never carry the doubt alone. Get tested, fix what can be fixed, visualize the win, and take action, because sitting in doubt, shame, or embarrassment is a dangerous place to live.

Dr. Jeremy Brook is a chiropractor in Encinitas, California, with 26 years in practice. Follow him on Instagram at @spinechecker and learn more at lightandbone.com.



A note from WeNatal on a father's perspective on trying to conceive

Jeremy's story holds two truths at the same time. He was healthy, dialed in, and confident, and he still carried the kind of quiet doubt that so many men hold without saying a word. That is exactly why we believe fertility is a shared journey from the very beginning. Men are 50% of the equation, not as a source of pressure or blame, but because their health, their habits, and their emotional experience matter too.

If there is one takeaway from this father's perspective on trying to conceive, it is the one Jeremy offered himself: trust the process, do the work, and never carry the doubt alone. For some men, that might mean booking a semen analysis, and for others it might mean telling a partner how the waiting really feels, finding a professional to talk to, or building a nutrition routine that supports you both as you prepare.

Start with a foundation built for him in WeNatal for Him, with 20 key nutrients to support healthy sperm cycles and beyond.* If you want the omega-3s Jeremy swears by, pair it with Omega DHA+ in the For Him + Omega DHA+ duo. And if you are preparing together, WeNatal Together gives both partners complete nutrition for egg and sperm quality, because the best support is shared.

Two Parents. Two Prenatals.


RELATED:
Can men take prenatal vitamins? An RDN explains







References

Agarwal A, Mulgund A, Hamada A, Chyatte MR. A unique view on male infertility around the globe. Reprod Biol Endocrinol. 2015;13:37. DOI: 10.1186/s12958-015-0032-1

Gnoth C, Godehardt D, Godehardt E, Frank-Herrmann P, Freundl G. Time to pregnancy: results of the German prospective study and impact on the management of infertility. Hum Reprod. 2003;18(9):1959-1966. DOI: 10.1093/humrep/deg366

Hickey SE, Curry CJ, Toriello HV. ACMG practice guideline: lack of evidence for MTHFR polymorphism testing. Genet Med. 2013;15(2):153-156. DOI: 10.1038/gim.2012.165

Johnson SL, Dunleavy J, Gemmell NJ, Nakagawa S. Consistent age-dependent declines in human semen quality: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Ageing Res Rev. 2015;19:22-33. DOI: 10.1016/j.arr.2014.10.007

Lynch CD, Sundaram R, Maisog JM, Sweeney AM, Buck Louis GM. Preconception stress increases the risk of infertility: results from a couple-based prospective cohort study, the LIFE study. Hum Reprod. 2014;29(5):1067-1075. DOI: 10.1093/humrep/deu032

Mínguez-Alarcón L, Gaskins AJ, Chiu YH, et al. Type of underwear worn and markers of testicular function among men attending a fertility center. Hum Reprod. 2018;33(9):1749-1756. DOI: 10.1093/humrep/dey259

Practice Committee of the American Society for Reproductive Medicine. Definitions of infertility and recurrent pregnancy loss: a committee opinion. Fertil Steril. 2020;113(3):533-535. DOI: 10.1016/j.fertnstert.2019.11.025

Salas-Huetos A, Rosique-Esteban N, Becerra-Tomás N, Vizmanos B, Bulló M, Salas-Salvadó J. The effect of nutrients and dietary supplements on sperm quality parameters: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized clinical trials. Adv Nutr. 2018;9(6):833-848. DOI: 10.1093/advances/nmy057

Schisterman EF, Sjaarda LA, Clemons T, et al. Effect of folic acid and zinc supplementation in men on semen quality and live birth among couples undergoing infertility treatment: a randomized clinical trial. JAMA. 2020;323(1):35-48. DOI: 10.1001/jama.2019.18714

Sheynkin Y, Jung M, Yoo P, Schulsinger D, Komaroff E. Increase in scrotal temperature in laptop computer users. Hum Reprod. 2005;20(2):452-455. DOI: 10.1093/humrep/deh616

Wilcox AJ, Weinberg CR, Baird DD. Timing of sexual intercourse in relation to ovulation: effects on the probability of conception, survival of the pregnancy, and sex of the baby. N Engl J Med. 1995;333(23):1517-1521. DOI: 10.1056/NEJM199512073332301



WeNatal Diaries share personal experiences and are not a substitute for individualized medical advice. The views expressed by contributors are their own. Talk with your healthcare provider about your own fertility, pregnancy, and supplement decisions.

These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.

Dr

Dr. Jeremy Brook

Dr. Jeremy Brook is an Encinitas Chiropractor, yogi, and movement specialist, whose mission is to create excellence in human performance and elevate consciousness in how we approach life from the way we breathe, move, feed our body and mind, and rest, to the way we connect to others. Since 2001, Dr. Brook has been offering chiropractic services to his local communities. First in Los Angeles at The Life Center Chiropractic, and now in Encinitas at Light + Bone Chiropractic. Light + Bone is a unique healing oasis that incorporates the disciplines of chiropractic, spinal corrective protocols, yoga, and other movement art forms to align the spine, body, and mind. Since 2005, Dr. Brook has been teaching an anthropological, evolutionary and energetic approach to Yoga Anatomy at several of America’s premier yoga studios. Dr. Brook is the founder of The Yoga of Chiropractic Adjusting seminar, a three-day intense experiential seminar for Doctors and students of Chiropractic. Dr. Brook is also an author. His book, The Spinechecker’s Manifesto is an integrative approach to healing and healthier living that incorporates vitalistic philosophy, metaphysics, epigenetics and simple step-by-step yogic sequences that will teach you how to align, move, stretch, strengthen, energize, and access the sacred geometry of your body and mind. When he’s not “spinechecking” and adjusting, he can be found on his yoga mat, lifting weights in his back yard, and wrestling with his 3 kids.

Trust the process, do the work: A father's perspective on trying to conceive